BlogSave Michigan


Last week, the Detroit News ran a stunning expose on the up-until-then secret meetings between Gov. Snyder’s executive office and Mackinac Center co-founder Richard McClellan. Their goal is simple: making a profit while educating our children by turning Michigan’s public education system into a voucher-like hybrid. They call their project “Skunk Works.”

The phrase “Skunk Works” is commonly used in business, and describes:

…a group within an organization given a high degree of autonomy and unhampered by bureaucracy, tasked with working on advanced or secret projects.

Setting aside for a moment the fact that “bureaucracy” in this case means undercutting nuisances like people we elected to represent our interests, “Skunk Works” is also the official alias for Lockheed Martin’s Advanced Development Programs and currently applies to one of the most expensive ($1 trillion) and over-budget projects (with grave field performance and pilot safety concerns) ever conceived by man: the F-35 Lightning II.

Does that sound familiar? Well it should, because a recent report raised these same concerns about Michigan’s expanding for-profit charter school system. In fact, most privatized government services see budgets overrun with poor results:

  • Federal government employees were less expensive than contractors in 33 of the 35 occupational classifications POGO reviewed.
  • In one instance, contractor billing rates were nearly 5 times more than the full compensation paid to federal employees performing comparable services.
  • Private sector compensation was lower than contractor billing rates in all 35 occupational classifications we reviewed.
  • The federal government has failed to determine how much money it saves or wastes by outsourcing, insourcing, or retaining services, and has no system for doing so.

The true irony of the Mackinac Center’s argument in favor of privatizing government services to save taxpayers money is that it’s simply not true. In reality, their entire existence is premised on the fact that private, for-profit companies are always more efficient than government and can always deliver equal or better services at a lower price. But that’s just not true; it has never been true.

However, this hasn’t prevented Gov. Rick Snyder’s office from meeting with the Mackinac Center’s co-founder behind closed doors with the goal of turning Michigan’s education system into another failed experiment in privatization. Just yesterday, he defended it by saying:

“That’s what I would view a group like that — just working together to say they want to come up with new ideas and throw them out there. That’s how you come up with new ideas. Most of them don’t go anywhere, but you don’t want to discourage people from trying and being creative.”

This, from the candidate who in 2010 promised, “As Governor, I will ensure that government is open, fair and accountable to the citizens by making Michigan a national leader in transparency and ethics.”

If you ask us, something stinks about Gov. Snyder’s “Skunk Works.” Call on Gov. Snyder to release all documents related to this project – including staff time and emails exchanged during normal business hours.


  1. Seems like Snyder and his cronies are the skunks here. Open, fair, and accountable are not words I’d use to describe this administration, either.

  2. This little nerd, represents what all adults hate about a sneaky, lying, hateful, child that can’t pull his own weight so goes behind everyone’s back to get his way. He has put up a Hugh road sign in Howell that is an embarrassment to all working people.

  3. Would Gov. Snyder been elected if he had run on a platform of privatizing public schools? Would he want his children to sit in front of computers that display text? No live teachers around? Why is the Michigan Republican Party inviting Michelle Rhee to attend their get together on Mackinac Island the end of May when everyone else knows she was a failure as a superintendent of the DC schools? (She now runs a business called StudentsFirst which is funded by Bill Gates, the Walton family, etc. For profit of course.)

    Michigan now has 300 for-profit charter schools, the largest number in the nation. These schools have no oversight. The public has no idea of how well students learn in these private schools. And, the Governor now supports a $700 million cut in revenue for our public schools. In short, he is a typical conservative Republican who is more concerned about rewarding campaign donors with millions in privatizing education contacts rather than caring if the result in the complete demise of public education.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Post comment